Which Exam is Tough: CAT or XAT?

Follow us on:

Author Name

Sourav Chakraborty

Updated on Apr 08, 2025 17:56


If you want to compare the difficulty level of the CAT and XAT exams, both are considered challenging in structure, question types, and test-taking strategies. CAT primarily focuses on Verbal Ability, Logical Reasoning, and Quantitative Aptitude, with a strong emphasis on time management and accuracy. On the other hand, XAT (Xavier Aptitude Test) includes additional Decision-Making and General Knowledge section, making it unique and requiring a broader skill set. While CAT is known for its tricky Quantitative Aptitude and time pressure, XAT is often seen as more unpredictable due to its Decision-Making section. The toughness of each exam depends on an aspirant's depth of knowledge and preparation strategy. In this article we will explain the difficult parts of these two exams.

XAT-vs-CAT

CAT Vs XAT Key Points

The table below, summarizes the key differences between CAT (Common Admission Test) and XAT (Xavier Aptitude Test):

FeatureCATXAT
Conducting BodyIIMs (Indian Institutes of Management)XLRI (Xavier Labour Relations Institute), Jamshedpur
PurposeAdmission to IIMs and other top B-schoolsAdmission to XLRI and other XAT-affiliated institutes
Exam Duration2 hours (120 minutes)3 hours (180 minutes)
Number of Sections3 (VARC, DILR, QA)4 (VALR, DM, QA, GK)
Section NamesVerbal Ability & Reading Comprehension (VARC) Data Interpretation & Logical Reasoning (DILR) Quantitative Aptitude (QA)

Verbal and Logical Ability (VALR) Decision Making (DM) Quantitative Ability & Data Interpretation (QA & DI)

General Knowledge (GK)

Sectional Time LimitYes (40 minutes per section)Yes (varies per section)
Essay WritingNoNo
Marking Scheme+3 for correct, -1 for incorrect+1 for correct, -0.25 for incorrect (except GK)
Difficulty LevelModerate to HighHigh (especially Decision Making and GK)

CAT VS XAT Exam Syllabus

CAT and XAT differ slightly in syllabus and exam structure. While both exams test candidates on Verbal Ability, Quantitative Ability, and Data Interpretation & Logical Reasoning, XAT includes additional sections on Decision Making and GK, which is unique to it. Moreover, XAT often features a more challenging Verbal section and also includes a General Knowledge section, unlike CAT. These differences make XAT slightly broader in scope and test a wider range of skills compared to CAT.

CAT Syllabus

Scetion-wise CAT 2025 syllabus is discussed below:

SectionTopics
Verbal Ability & Reading Comprehension (VARC)Para jumbles, para summary, odd one out, sentence completion, and 4 RCs with 4 questions each.
Data Interpretation & Logical Reasoning (DILR)Tables, bar graphs, pie charts, line arrangements, circular arrangement, and selection-based questions.
Quantitative Aptitude (QA)Arithmetic, algebra, geometry, number system, and modern math-based questions.

XAT Syllabus

Compared to CAT exam, XAT syllabus is bit more extensive due to two additional sections such as DM and GK.

XAT Syllabus
SectionTopics
Verbal Ability (VA)Questions based on poems, critical reasoning, RC, vocabulary, synonyms, antonyms, jumbled paragraphs, sentence completion, etc.
Decision Making (DM)Based on assumptions, premises, ethics, HR, business issues, and analytical reasoning.
Quantitative Aptitude (QA)Diagrams, charts, graphs, permutation & combination, probability, trigonometry, inequality, binomial, progression, Venn diagrams, logarithm, linear equations, mensuration, speed-time-distance, percentages, algebra, geometry, etc.
General Knowledge (GK)Based on business, finance, economics, constitution laws, personalities, awards, current affairs of national and international importance.

Comparatively XAT has a lengthy syllabus than CAT. Students preparing for XAT need to dedicate more time to prepare for XAT than CAT.

CAT vs XAT: Exam Pattern and Marking Scheme

The number of questions varies in both exams. CAT had 68 questions in 2024, while XAT has 95 questions to be attempted by the candidates. However, CAT and XAT differ significantly in their marking schemes as well. It should also be noted that XAT penalizes -0.1 marks for every 8 un-attempted questions. However, XAT GK paper doesn't have any negative marking.

Overall, both CAT and XAT exams are strict in penalizing the candidate for wrong answers, but given the weightage of marks, CAT seems to be tougher than the two.

DetailsCAT Marking Scheme / Time Duration

XAT Marking Scheme /

Time Duration

Number of Questions6895
Total Marks19895
Negative Marking

3 marks for correct answer.

(-1) mark for incorrect answer.

No negative marking for non-MCQs.

1 mark for correct answer.

(-0.25) mark for incorrect answer.

(-0.5) marks for more than 8 un-attempted questions.

No negative marking in GK section.

Number of choices in MCQs45
Sectional Time Limit40 minutes per section (120 minutes in total)170 minutes for Part 1 (VA, QA, DM) 10 minutes for GK

CAT vs XAT Time Limits

Candidates of entrance exams often struggle with the time management, and success comes to those who can manage the time efficiently. Before going for the examination hall candidates must know that CAT has section-wise time limits. CAT candidates cannot move to any sections without completing the previous one.

CAT Exam SectionsTime Duration (in minutes)
VARC (Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension)40
LRDI (Logical Reasoning and Data Interpretation)40
QUANTS (Quantitative Ability)40

Candidates aspiring for XAT does not have any sectional time limits. For the first part of the exam consisting of VALR, DM, and QA & DI candidates will get 170 minutes, while for the second part of the XAT question paper candidates will get 10 minutes for GK paper.

XAT Exam PartsTime Duration (in minutes)
Part 1

Verbal Ability & Logical Reasoning (VA & LR)

Decision-Making (DM)

Quantitative Aptitude & Data Interpretation (QA & DI)

170
Part 2General Knowledge (GK)10

Number of Questions in CAT vs XAT Exam

If you compare the number of questions in CAT vs XAT, XAT exam will appear tougher as the number of questions are 95 in XAT while CAT questions paper consists of only 66 to 68 questions. Though candidates will get 1 hour more in XAT compared to CAT, it requires unwavering determination and resilience to successfully complete the XAT paper.

CAT Exam: Number of Questions Asked
SectionNo. of Questions
VARC (Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension)24
LRDI (Logical Reasoning and Data Interpretation)22
QUANTS (Quantitative Ability)22
Total68

XAT question paper has 4 to 6 more questions in VA & LR and QA & DI section compared to CAT.

XAT Exam: Number of Questions Asked
SectionNo. of Questions
Verbal Ability & Logical Reasoning (VA & LR)26
Decision-Making (DM)21
Quantitative Aptitude & Data Interpretation (QA & DI)28
General Knowledge (GK)20
Total95

CAT vs XAT Section-wise Difficulty Level

In CAT 2024, there was a minor change to its exam format by increasing the total number of questions from 66 to 68. The Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension (VARC) section proved to be the toughest, whereas the Quantitative Ability (QA) section was relatively easier and more manageable. The Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning (DILR) section offered a balanced mix of difficulty and scoring opportunities.

CAT 2024 Section-wise Difficulty Level

SectionTotal QuestionsDifficulty LevelNo. of MCQ QuestionsNo. of TITA QuestionsGood Attempts
VARC24Moderate22217-18
DILR22Easy - Moderate101212-13
QA22Moderate81413-14
TOTAL68Moderate204845-47

XAT 2025 Section-wise Difficulty Level

In the part 1 of XAT 2025 exam, candidates, who attempted about 13-14 out of 26 questions in the Verbal Ability and Logical Reasoning Section in about 55-60 minutes, with 80% accuracy rate can expect good score.

XAT Verbal Ability and Logical Reasoning Section

Area / QuestionsNo. of Qs.Level of Difficulty
Grammatically correct sentence2Medium
Fill in the blanks (4 blanks)1Medium
Jumbled Paragraphs (5 statements)2Medium
Critical Reasoning3Medium
Main idea/message of the given image1Medium
RC Passages - 5 (300-450 words)15Difficult
Poem-based passage2Difficult

XAT Decision Making Section (21 Questions)

Decision Making section of XAT 2025 consisted of 7 sets of 3 questions each. Candidates attempting 11-12 questions in about 55 minutes with 75-80% accuracy should expect good score.

XAT Quantitative Aptitude (16 Questions)

In the QA and DI section of XAT 2025, which consist of 28 questions, an attempt of approximately 18-19 questions with around 80% accuracy within 55-60 minutes would be considered a strong performance.

TopicEasyMediumDifficultTotal
Arithmetic2103
Geometry1225
Modern Math0123
Algebra2103
Numbers0112
Total QA56516

XAT Data Interpretation (12 Questions)

Set TypeEasyMediumDifficultTotal
Scatter Plot / Line Graph (observation-based)0303
Arithmetic-based set0303
Average-based set0303
Number-matrix based set0303
Total DI012012

CAT VS XAT Cutoffs

XAT cutoffs for XLRI are generally higher, with the Business Management (BM) program requiring a 95+ percentile and the Human Resource Management (HRM) program needing around 92+. This is higher than the CAT cutoffs for most IIMs. Other top B-schools, such as SPJIMR, XIMB, and IMT, have similar cutoffs for both CAT and XAT exams, typically ranging between 85-90 percentile. While both CAT and XAT have sectional cutoffs, IIMs tend to enforce stricter sectional time limits and marks weightage, making it essential for candidates to perform well across all sections. The following table shows the cutoffs of some of the top CAT and XAT affiliated management colleges.

B-SchoolCAT Cutoff (Percentile)XAT Cutoff (Percentile)
IIM Ahmedabad80 (Overall)Not Applicable
IIM Bangalore85 (Overall)Not Applicable
IIM Calcutta85 (Overall)Not Applicable
XLRI Jamshedpur (BM)Not Applicable95+ (Overall)
XLRI Jamshedpur (HRM)Not Applicable92+ (Overall)
SPJIMR Mumbai85+90+

XIMB

9090
IMT Ghaziabad9090
TAPMI Manipal8585
Great Lakes Chennai8585
GIM Goa8585
KJ Somaiya8383

When comparing CAT and XAT in terms of time management and question marking weightage, CAT tends to be more challenging due to its strict time constraints. Each section in CAT has a fixed time limit, making it extremely important for candidates to manage their time efficiently under pressure. XAT, on the other hand, provides more flexibility in navigating through sections.

Despite both exams being competitive, CAT is more popular as it serves as the gateway to India's top business schools, including the IIMs and premier private institutes. XAT, on the other hand, is primarily for Xavier schools of management and a few other colleges. This broader acceptance makes CAT the preferred choice for a larger pool of MBA aspirants in India.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Ans: The Quantitative Ability & Data Interpretation section of both XAT and CAT are highly scoring. However, XAT's Verbal Ability and Decision-Making questions and CAT's VARC and Logical Reasoning sections are quite challenging. Students targeting high scores in these sections of both exams need to prepare and practice more carefully.

Ans: No, preparing separately for XAT is necessary since its question paper, question types, and test structure differ significantly from CAT.  Since CAT and XAT share common sections like Quantitative Ability (QA), Data Interpretation & Logical Reasoning (DILR), and Verbal Ability (VARC), your CAT preparation will cover a significant portion of XAT. However, there are key differences:

  • Decision Making (DM) Section – This is exclusive to XAT and requires practice with ethical dilemmas, business scenarios, and logical reasoning-based case studies. CAT does not have this section, so you'll need to prepare separately for it.
  • Verbal Ability Difficulty – XAT’s Verbal Ability questions are often trickier, with a strong emphasis on critical reasoning and inference-based RCs, which might be more difficult than CAT’s VARC.
  • Quant Section – While both exams test Quant, XAT is slightly more concept-driven and includes a mix of higher-level arithmetic and geometry-based questions.
  • General Knowledge (GK) Section – XAT includes a GK section, which is not part of CAT. Although GK is not considered for shortlisting in XLRI, it matters in the final selection round.

Ans: The Decision-Making section of XAT consists of 21 questions, carrying a total of 21 marks. Candidates are required to answer a set of inference-based questions for each passage. These passages can be either mathematical or behavioral in nature. Mathematical questions typically involve Data Interpretation or Logical Reasoning sets. The behavioral questions are scenario-based, where candidates must select the most appropriate solution to a given situation.

Ans: In addition to XLRI Jamshedpur, over 800 MBA colleges in India accept XAT scores. Some of the well-known institutes include XIMB, XISS, LIBA, GIM Goa, GLIM, TAPMI, KIIT SOM, IMT Ghaziabad, and Birla Institute of Management Technology.

Ans: More than 1,300 management institutes in India, including private and government institutions (all the IIMs) as well as central and state universities, accept CAT scores for MBA admissions.

Get College Notifications, Exam Notifications and News Updates